News & Notes

Spot the Fake

Posted in Resources, Special Collections Tagged with:

In 2010, a woman brought a copy of the July 2/4, 1863, edition of the Vicksburg Daily Citizen for an appraisal on the popular PBS series, Antiques Roadshow, at the time touring in Biloxi, Mississippi.  An especially famous newspaper, this particular issue announced the fall of the city to Union troops on Independence Day, but it would become best known as the most renowned of the Confederate “wallpaper newspapers.”  Midway through the war, when newsprint began to run low around the South, many small town publishers substituted the only paper available.  Likewise, when surrounded by Federal forces and cut off from supplies of paper, the publisher of the Daily Citizen also had to settle for wallpaper to print six editions of his newspaper in the last days of the siege.

So what was it worth?  Well, not much.  Appraiser Wesley Cowen easily determined it was a fake—one of many replicas made in the decades after the war as souvenirs or curiosities.

So, would you know the difference?  The LSU Libraries Special Collections has a genuine copy of this deservedly famous newspaper, as well as several not-so-genuine imitations.  Take a look at these two and see if you can spot the fake.

1 DC whole page copy

2 DC whole page copy

 

Can’t tell?  The second one is the impostor.  We can tell by comparing both papers against ten facts known about the original as described in a circular from the Library of Congress.  Let’s look at just a few.

Column 1, Line 2: “J.M. Swords,……Proprietor” includes a comma (or imperfect dot) and six periods.

4 DC Original zoom copy

REAL

6 DC Fake zoom copy
FAKE

Column 4, Paragraph 3, Line 7: The first word is misspelled “Secossion.”

14 DC Original Secession flags zoom copy

REAL

16 DC Fake Secession flags zoom copy
FAKE

Column 4, Last article before Note: The final word is printed with the quotation mark misplaced, ‘dead’ instead of dead.”

9 DC Original If we had zoom copy

REAL

12 DC Fake If we had the  zoom copy
FAKE

Column 4, Note, Line 1: A comma follows the word “changes” rather than a period.

8 DC Original Two days zoom copy

REAL

11 DC Fake Two days zoom copy
FAKE

Although seldom printed to deceive collectors, reproductions of famous newspapers are everywhere.  If you think you might have one, consult the Library of Congress’ information circulars on authenticating old newspapers and caveat emptor!

For more about Confederate wallpaper printing, see “Beautiful Necessity: Wallpaper and Confederate Imprints” by Jessica Lacher-Feldman in the Civil War Book Review.

Hans Rasmussen is Coordinator of Special Collections Technical Services in the LSU Libraries.

Posted in Resources, Special Collections Tagged with:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Contact Special Collections

Public Services Desk: (225) 578-6544

Reference Desk: (225) 578-6568

Fax: (225) 578-9425

Email: special@lsu.edu

Reference via e-mail


RSS Feed
 RSS - Special Collections Posts

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 6 other subscribers

Special Collections Hours

Special Collections on Twitter: @whatintheHill

Special Collections on Facebook: LSUspecialcollections

You are protected by wp-dephorm: